Channel

The Effects Of Wood

Another factor that affects the quality of a violin is the internal damping of the wood. This strongly affects the multi-resonant response of the instrument and the overall background at high frequencies. In particular, the difference between the peaks and troughs of the resonant response is determined by the quality-factor of the resonances. This largely depends on internal losses within the wood when it vibrates: only a small fraction of the energy is lost by acoustic radiation.

The strongly peaked frequency response of the violin has a dramatic influence on the sound produced when "vibrato" is used. In this playing technique, the finger stopping the string is cyclically rocked backwards and forwards, periodically changing the pitch of the note. Because the response has such strong peaks and troughs, any change in pitch also produces cyclic variations in the overall amplitude, waveform and spectral content of the sound.

Vibrato is very common nowadays because it captures and holds the attention of the listener, enabling the solo violin to be heard even when accompanied by a large orchestra. It would have been considered far less important when Stradivari was alive because vibrato was used only for special theatrical effects and the violin was expected to blend in with other instruments.

Vibrato adds a certain "lustre" and interest to the quality of sound produced because the ear is particularly sensitive to changes in the waveform. In a recent radio broadcast, for example, the English violinist Tasmin Little demonstrated the marvellous tone of the Stradivarius violin used by Nathan Milstein, one of the finest violinists of recent times. After playing just a few notes on the violin, she described the tone as "wonderfully exciting, almost deafening, very vibrant. It is alive. It has an incredible ring under my ear. It is amazing". There can be little doubt that Little's subjective assessment is directly related to the extremely large changes in amplitude, waveform and spectral content associated with the use of vibrato, which gives "life and vibrancy" to the sound.

To achieve such large changes in the frequency response of the violin, the individual resonances of the instrument have to be strongly peaked, which requires high-quality wood with low internal damping. Unfortunately, wood can absorb water, which increases the damping: this explains why violinists often notice that the responsiveness of an instrument, which includes the ability to control the sound quality using vibrato, changes with temperature and humidity.

The choice of high-quality wood for making instruments has always been recognized by violin makers, and well seasoned wood is generally recommended. However, by measuring the pattern of growth-rings in the wood of a Stradivarius, we know that the Italian violin makers sometimes used planks of wood that had only been seasoned for five years. However, such wood is now 300 years old, and the intrinsic internal damping will almost certainly have decreased with time, as the internal organic structure has dried out.

The same will obviously be true for all old Italian instruments. The age of the wood may therefore automatically contribute to the improved quality of the older instruments. This may also explain why the quality of a modern instrument appears to change in its first few years. Surprisingly, many players still believe that their instruments improve because they are loved and played well, which would be very difficult to explain on any rational scientific basis!